Player Commitments
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos. | Commitment |
| Joseph Carucci | NY | Yorktown | 2025 | OF | Monmouth |
| Gregory Carullo | NY | Commack | 2020 | C | SUNY-Oswego |
| Ryan Caruso | AZ | Corona Del Sol | 2025 | RHP | Arizona State |
| Mike Caruso | CT | Lyman Hall | 2017 | C | Fairfield |
| JT Caruso | NY | Mount Sinai | 2023 | LHP | Miami |
| Charlie Caruso | CA | JSerra | 2024 | C | Northwestern |
| Michael Caruso | AZ | Desert Vista | 2023 | RHP | San Diego State |
| Cole Caruso | AZ | Cactus Shadows | 2021 | SS | USC-Upstate |
| Joey Caruso | TN | Collierville | 2023 | 2B | Alabama-Huntsville |
| Alex Caruso | VA | Appomattox | 2023 | RHP | Hampden-Sydney College |
| Cal Caruso | NY | Monroe Woodbury | 2020 | 3B | Lesley University |
| Steve Caruso | PA | Garnet Valley | 2018 | C | Neumann College |
| Jacob Caruso | OH | Rootstown | 2019 | C | Thomas More |
| Anthony Caruso | IL | Streamwood | 2019 | 3B | Wisconsin-Oshkosh |
| Luke Caruso | CA | Sage Creek | 2023 | SS | Biola University |
| Oscar Carvajal | CA | Gahr | 2016 | RHP | Fresno State |
| Jorge Carvajal | DR | Neiba | 2021 | RHP | Arizona Western JC |
| Kevin Carvalho | GA | North Gwinnett | 2018 | RHP | Southwestern Illinois JC |
| Michael Carvatta | IL | Maine South | 2019 | OF | Prairie State JC |
| Jase Carvell | TN | Lawrence County | 2015 | LHP | Trevecca Nazarene |
| Louis Carvell | NY | NYC Lab School for Collaborative Studies | 2019 | SS | SUNY-Purchase |
| Robbie Carvelli | NJ | St. Joseph of Metuchen | 2023 | OF | Lehigh |
| Johnny Carver | MO | Ray-Pec | 2026 | LHP | Arkansas |
| Christian Carver | VA | Freedom (South Riding) | 2023 | SS | George Mason |
| Jack Carver | FL | Allen D. Nease | 2020 | LHP | Jacksonville |
| Colin Carver | CT | Valley Regional | 2023 | RHP | Marist |
| Cal Carver | TX | Reagan | 2018 | LHP | Wichita State |
| John Carver | NY | Lynbrook | 2021 | RHP | Adelphi University |
| Chase Carver | KY | Warren East | 2023 | SS | Bellarmine University |
| Jack Carver | PA | Central Bucks South | 2023 | RHP | Bloomsburg University |
| Ryan Carver | FL | Oakleaf | 2014 | OF | Lake Erie College |
| Randall Carver | TX | Smithson Valley | 2020 | RHP | Hendrix College |
| Jack Carver | CO | Douglas County | 2023 | C | Nebraska Wesleyan |
| Sam Carver | KS | Ottawa | 2015 | LHP | Coffeyville CC |
| Ross Carver | AR | Benton High School | 2017 | RHP | Crowder JC |
| Breck Carver | TX | NOC Tonkawa | 2021 | RHP | Hill JC |
| Blade Carver | TX | Denton Guyer | 2023 | C | NOC Tonkowa |
| Connor Carver | OH | Beavercreek | 2021 | RHP | WSU-Lake |
| Mack Carver | AR | De Queen | 2019 | C | Ecclesia College |
| Cody Carwile | FL | Fleming Island | 2021 | LHP | Georgia Tech |
| Sean Cary | IL | Centralia | 2016 | SS | Evansville |
| Peyton Cary | KY | Muhlenberg county | 2024 | LHP | Morehead State |
| Josh Cary | MN | St. Anthony Village | 2020 | - | Hamline University |
| Devyn Cary | NE | Syracuse | 2017 | RHP | Midland Univrsity |
| Carter Casabella | TN | Station Camp | 2024 | RHP | Tennessee Tech |
| Joshua Casado | NJ | Memorial WNY | 2018 | RHP | Wagner |
| Tyler Casagrande | VA | Riverside | 2018 | OF | Arizona |
| Logan Casala | MA | Seekonk | 2019 | C | Mitchell College |
| Johnny Casale | AZ | Brophy Prep | 2024 | LHP | Loyola Marymount |
| Joseph Casale | FL | Jesuit | 2020 | SS | Adrian College |
| Mikey Casaleggio | NJ | Indian Hills | 2017 | SS | Marist |
| Nick Casaleggio | NJ | Indian Hills | 2018 | RHP | Rutgers State-Newark |
| Noah Casali | WI | Middleton | 2018 | 2B | Greenville College |
| Adam Casali | WI | Middleton | 2020 | C | Wisconsin-Whitewater |
| Danny Casals | FL | Christopher Columbus | 2015 | SS | Maine |
| Cole Casamento | PA | Spring-Ford | 2021 | C | Lackawanna JC |
| Tony Casanova | FL | Christopher Columbus | 2021 | 1B | Florida International |
| Luke Casanova | MN | Eagan | 2020 | OF | St. John's University (MN |
| Alex Casarella | NY | Fox Lane | 2021 | RHP | Fordham |
| Triston Casas | FL | American Heritage | 2018 | 1B | Miami |
| Gavin Casas | FL | American Heritage Plantation | 2020 | 1B | Vanderbilt |
| Ethan Casas-Wu | CA | Aragon | 2022 | C | College of San Mateo |
| Josh Casavan | MN | Lafayette | 2018 | - | Northland CC & Tech |
| Anthony Casciato | PA | Pittsburgh Central Catholic | 2017 | 2B | Mercyhurst North East JC |
| Frank Cascio | NJ | Pascack Valley | 2017 | OF | Quinnipiac |
| Daniel Cascio | CT | East Hampton | 2022 | 1B | Rhode Island College |
| Anthony Casciola | NC | Weddington | 2019 | RHP | Bucknell |
| Jaxon Casdia | NJ | Cherry Hill West | 2023 | LHP | Rowan University |
| TJ Case | IL | Willowbrook | 2014 | RHP | High Point |
| Carson Case | CA | Foothill | 2021 | 3B | Nevada |
| Cash Case | FL | The First Academy | 2017 | SS | Notre Dame |
| David Case | CA | Loyola | 2021 | LHP | Oregon State |
| Thomas Case | NY | Shaker | 2025 | RHP | St. John's |
| Jackson Case | KY | Trinity | 2020 | SS | Bellarmine University |
| Jaden Case | MN | Shakopee | 2023 | LHP | Minnesota State |
| Harper Case | TN | Tullahoma | 2016 | LHP | Alabama-Huntsville |
| Vinnie Case | PA | William Tennent | 2014 | OF | Alvernia University |
| Payton Case | MN | Shakopee | 2019 | 3B | Wisconsin-Stout |
| Logan Case | OH | Vandalia-Butler | 2020 | SS | Asbury University |
| Jaxon Case | CO | Heritage | 2024 | OF | Barton CC |
| Walker Case | NC | Brevard | 2020 | RHP | Catawba Valley CC |
| Caleb Case | OK | Stillwater | 2019 | LHP | Cowley County CC |
| Will Case | MI | North Huron | 2022 | RHP | Lansing CC |
| Noah Case | ON | Richview Collegiate Institute | 2019 | 3B | Murray State JC |
| Joe Case | NY | Homer | 2022 | 3B | Onondaga CC |
| Zackarie Casebonne | LA | Jesuit | 2021 | C | Dartmouth |
| Will Casel | IA | Ankeny Hawks | 2018 | LHP | Des Moines Area CC |
| Joey Casella | NY | Westlake | 2024 | OF | Alvernia University |
| Mitchael Casement | KS | Maize | 2021 | C | Sterling College |
| Jaycob Caseres | FL | Community School of Naples | 2021 | C | Pittsburgh-Greensburg |
| Joe Caserio | OH | Mayfield | 2015 | OF | Ashland |
| Lucas Casey | AZ | Canyon Del Oro | 2023 | OF | Cal State Northridge |
| Jake Casey | NY | Homer Senior | 2014 | - | Canisius |
| Jake Casey | PA | Upper St. Clair | 2021 | SS | Kent State |
| Derek Casey | VA | Hanover | 2014 | RHP | Virginia |
| Garrett Casey | GA | Troup County | 2019 | LHP | William & Mary |
| Tim Casey | OH | LaSalle | 2016 | 2B | Ashland |
| Tim Casey | PA | Council Rock North | 2015 | RHP | Chestnut Hill College |
| Collin Casey | NY | Marlboro | 2022 | C | College of Saint Rose |
| Kamden Casey | IL | Freeburg | 2022 | RHP | McKendree University |