Player Commitments
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos. | Commitment |
| Steven Colon | NY | James Monroe | 2018 | RHP | Sullivan County CC |
| Josh Colon | IL | Lyons Township | 2021 | SS | Frontier CC |
| Justin Colon | IL | Dundee Crown | 2021 | OF | Southern Maine CC |
| Steven Colon Jr | OK | Deer Creek | 2020 | SS | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| Michael Colonna | NC | Weddington | 2022 | RHP | North Carolina |
| Michael Colonnello | NJ | Sayreville | 2023 | OF | Kean University |
| Morgan Colopy | OH | Centerville | 2019 | OF | Cincinnati |
| Preston Colp | FL | Palm Beach Gardens | 2018 | 1B | Saint Anselm |
| Justin Colpack | MA | Easthampton | 2022 | 1B | Wheaton College (MA) |
| Tyler Colpitts | IN | Goshen | 2018 | RHP | Manchester College |
| Charlie Colson | OH | Dublin Coffman | 2024 | OF | Capital University |
| Grant Colson | TX | The Woodlands College Park | 2023 | RHP | Brookhaven JC |
| Caden Colson | TN | Upperman | 2023 | RHP | Chattanooga State CC |
| CJ Colson Jr. | OH | Beachwood | 2016 | SS | Sinclair CC |
| JP Colton | FL | Winter Park | 2015 | OF | Navy |
| Joey Colucci | VA | Woodgrove | 2022 | RHP | Maryland |
| Jake Colucci | VA | Frank W. Cox | 2024 | RHP | UNC Greensboro |
| Don Colucci | PA | Neshannock | 2015 | 1B | Slippery Rock |
| Anthony Colucci | NJ | Morris Knolls | 2020 | RHP | Susquehanna |
| Drew Colucci | CT | Trumbull | 2024 | 3B | Wentworth Institute of Te |
| Ryan Colucci | IL | Lake Park | 2024 | 2B | Southwestern Illinois JC |
| Zach Coluccio | NJ | Timber Creek | 2021 | RHP | Widener University |
| Nicholas Columbano | NY | Commack | 2023 | 2B | Curry College |
| Collin Columbus | MN | Como Park | 2018 | - | Anoka-Ramsey CC |
| Jake Columbus | PA | California Area | 2014 | C | Westmoreland County CC |
| Ben Columbus | BC | Sentinel Secondary | 2020 | C | Wharton County JC |
| Cutter Colvert | AR | Lonoke | 2024 | 3B | Neosho County CC |
| Clayton Colvin | OH | Dublin Jerome | 2015 | RHP | Cincinnati |
| Kendall Colvin | OH | Kenton Ridge | 2013 | RHP | Oakland |
| Jimmy Colvin | PA | Cathedral Prep | 2019 | RHP | Gannon University |
| Wyatt Colvin | KY | North Oldham | 2024 | RHP | Hanover College |
| Cash Colvin | OK | Tuttle | 2018 | LHP | Southwestern Christian |
| Cameron Colwell | PA | Seton-La Salle Catholic | 2021 | C | Seton Hill |
| Gavin Colwell | VA | Halifax County | 2021 | RHP | Averett University |
| Jack Colyar | PA | Archbishop Wood | 2019 | RHP | Duke |
| Jack Colyer | PA | Perkiomen Valley | 2022 | RHP | Ithaca College |
| Kevin Comblo | NJ | St. Joseph's Montvale | 2027 | C | Texas Christian |
| Caiden Combs | AL | Gardendale | 2025 | 1B | Auburn |
| Aaron Combs | FL | IMG Academy | 2020 | RHP | Coastal Carolina |
| Avery Combs | VA | E.C. Glass | 2017 | 3B | Hofstra |
| Brayden Combs | KY | Beechwood | 2016 | 1B | Kentucky |
| Jake Combs | TX | Cypress Ranch | 2019 | RHP | Louisiana-Lafayette |
| Scott Combs | MI | Divine Child | 2017 | C | Michigan State |
| Shane Combs | MA | St. John's Shrewsbury | 2015 | RHP | Notre Dame |
| Cameron Combs | KY | Corbin | 2023 | C | Bellarmine University |
| Sean Combs | MO | Liberty North | 2023 | OF | Emporia State University |
| Josh Combs | AZ | Sunnyslope | 2020 | LHP | Point Loma Nazarene |
| Aaron Combs | MD | James M. Bennett | 2020 | RHP | Salisbury |
| Brandon Combs | WV | Charleston Catholic | 2018 | 3B | Transylvania |
| John Combs | TN | Rhea County | 2021 | C | Milligan College |
| Colin Combs | KY | Bishop Brossart | 2023 | C | Olivet Nazarene |
| Dalton Combs | IN | Adams Central | 2013 | OF | Huntington University (IN |
| Taylor Combs | KY | Corbin Independent HS | 2014 | RHP | Berea College |
| Hunter Combs | KY | Muhlenberg County | 2017 | C | John A. Logan JC |
| Cooper Combs | AR | Springdale | 2021 | OF | Johnson County CC |
| Rorey Combs | MO | Truman | 2016 | OF | Kansas City Kansas CC |
| Stephen Combs | FL | TNXL Academy | 2024 | OF | Oakton CC |
| Justin Combs | KY | Barren County | 2019 | LHP | Roane State CC |
| Connor Combs | OH | Waynesville | 2013 | 3B | Sinclair CC |
| Cade Combs | OH | Harrison | 2022 | C | IU-Kokomo |
| Grant Comeaux | LA | Barbe | 2022 | 3B | Louisiana Tech |
| Donald Comeaux | LA | North Vermillion | 2015 | RHP | Louisiana-Lafayette |
| Braden Comeaux | LA | Barbe | 2015 | SS | Rice |
| Ryan Comella | KY | St. Xavier | 2024 | C | Charleston (WV) |
| Jeremy Comer | KS | St James Academy | 2023 | OF | Tennessee |
| Hudson Comer | CA | El Segundo | 2024 | OF | UC Irvine |
| Cam Comer | OH | Olentangy Liberty | 2015 | C | Virginia |
| Carson Comer | OH | Olentangy Liberty | 2018 | C | Alderson Broaddus |
| Brad Comer | WI | Rhinelander | 2018 | 3B | Winona State University |
| Brody Comer | MD | Century | 2023 | 3B | McDaniel College |
| Brian Comer | NC | Independence | 2018 | OF | Guilford Technical CC |
| Caden Comer | NE | North Platte | 2018 | RHP | Southeast CC |
| Brendan Comerford | CA | Foothill | 2023 | SS | St. Mary's |
| Reece Comerford | MI | Plainwell | 2020 | C | Albion College |
| Bennett Comes | WA | Ferris | 2020 | 1B | Centralia College |
| Cade Cometti | OK | Coalgate | 2024 | RHP | Connors State JC |
| Anthony Comfort | NE | Bennington | 2020 | LHP | Southwestern CC |
| Jared Comia | IN | Hanover Central | 2021 | OF | Illinois |
| Jayden Comia | IL | Sandburg | 2022 | SS | Illinois |
| Branden Comia | IL | Sandburg | 2018 | SS | Illinois |
| Joe Comins | NY | West Genesee | 2019 | OF | Misericordia |
| Cam Comins | VA | Millbrook | 2023 | RHP | Shenandoah |
| Joey Cominsky | PA | Hamburg Area | 2014 | RHP | Pittsburgh |
| Carter Comisford | OH | Northridge High School | 2019 | 2B | Ohio Northern |
| Connor Comiskey | MI | Lutheran High North | 2022 | RHP | Calvin College |
| Chris Comito | IA | Norwalk | 2015 | RHP | Iowa |
| Jake Commens | PA | Quaker Valley | 2019 | LHP | McDaniel College |
| Cole Commisso | OH | Tinora | 2022 | 2B | Findlay |
| Zachary Common | OH | Kent Roosevelt | 2020 | SS | Bellarmine University |
| Chris Common | PA | Penn-Trafford | 2015 | OF | Pittsburgh-Greensburg |
| Grant Como | NJ | Westfield | 2025 | LHP | Brown |
| Jean Paul Compres | NY | William C. Bryant | 2017 | C | Sullivan County CC |
| Alan Compres | NJ | Hackensack | 2022 | OF | Wells College |
| Brandon Compton | AZ | Buckeye Union | 2022 | LHP | Arizona State |
| Drew Compton | NJ | Governor Livingston | 2019 | 3B | Georgia Tech |
| Mason Compton | GA | Flowery Branch | 2023 | RHP | Wofford |
| Nick Compton | OH | Keystone | 2020 | OF | Findlay |
| Brady Compton | OH | Berea-Midpark | 2021 | RHP | Baldwin Wallace |
| Douglas Compton | OH | Summit Country Day | 2014 | OF | DePauw University |
| Benjamin Compton | MI | Rochester | 2017 | 2B | Olivet College |