| Rank | Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| 1 | Matt Smoral | OH | Solon | 2012 | LHP | North Carolina |
| 2 | Taylore Cherry | OH | Vandalia Butler | 2012 | RHP | North Carolina |
| 3 | Luke Stephenson | IN | Triton Central | 2012 | RHP | Vanderbilt University |
| 4 | Brett Lilek | IL | Marian Catholic HS | 2012 | LHP | Arizona State University |
| 5 | Xavier Turner | OH | Sandusky | 2012 | 3B | Vanderbilt |
| 6 | Jason Goldstein | IL | Highland Park HS | 2012 | C | Illinois |
| 7 | Jordan Minch | IN | Highland | 2012 | LHP | Purdue University |
| 8 | Kyle Funkhouser | IL | Oak Forest HS | 2012 | RHP | Louisville |
| 9 | Ryan Koziol | IL | Providence Catholic | 2012 | MIF | Arizona |
| 10 | Anthony Kidston | OH | Defiance | 2012 | RHP | Louisville |