Preseason All-State - Downstate
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Justin Adams | NY | Westlake | 2016 | 3B | Plattsburgh State University of New York |
| John Adimari | CT | Greenwich | 2016 | RHP | |
| Gaetano Annunziata | NY | Fordham Prep | 2015 | C | |
| Jason Apostle | NY | Fordham Prep | 2017 | OF | |
| Matthew Aventuro | NY | Fordham Prep | 2018 | OF | |
| Angelo Baez | NY | Mount St. Michael Academy | 2016 | SS | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Nick Bilotta | NY | Harrison | 2017 | 2B | |
| Steven Boscia | NY | Stepinac | 2016 | RHP | Hofstra |
| Gabriel Corser Figueroa | NY | Croton Harmon | 2017 | RHP | |
| Thomas Cosentino | NY | Westlake | 2016 | LHP | |
| Tyler Cowles | NY | Sleepy Hollow | 2016 | 2B | |
| Matthew Crowe | NY | Dobbs Ferry | 2015 | OF | |
| Dylan Dasgupta | NY | New Rochelle | 2016 | RHP | |
| Brendan Duane | NY | Westlake | 2015 | LHP | |
| Tim Eidem | NY | Ossining | 2016 | SS | |
| Matteo Falcone | NY | Stepinac | 2018 | OF | Ursinus College |
| Christopher Gaeta | NY | Harrison | 2017 | C | |
| Brett Holtz | NY | Valhalla | 2017 | 1B | Columbia |
| Thomas Hunter | NY | Salesian | 2016 | LHP | |
| CJ Iametti | NJ | Don Bosco Prep | 2017 | C | SUNY-Oneonta |
| Justin Jimenez | NY | Salesian | 2016 | RHP | |
| Daniel Klein | NY | Harrison | 2017 | OF | |
| Matthew Latino | NY | Westlake | 2016 | SS | |
| Daniel Lotito | NY | White Plains | 2016 | LHP | |
| Christian Lovecchio | NY | Valhalla | 2016 | C | |
| Nick Mazone | NY | Bethlehem | 2016 | RHP | |
| Timothy Moore | NY | Ossining | 2016 | RHP | |
| Christian Naccari | NY | Ossining | 2016 | SS | Nichols College |
| Evan Noblesala | NY | Townsend Harris | 2016 | 2B | |
| Joseph Ragone | NY | Stepinac | 2018 | SS | SUNY Maritime |
| Ryan Ragone | NY | Stepinac | 2018 | RHP | SUNY Maritime |