Preseason All-State - Long Island
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Vincent Barretta | NY | St. Anthony's | 2017 | 2B | |
| Ryan Calkins | NY | Division Avenue | 2017 | C | |
| Matthew Carey | NY | Oceanside | 2018 | RHP | New York Institute of Technology |
| Brendan Cummins | NY | Blind Brook | 2017 | SS | |
| EJ Exposito | NY | St. John the Baptist | 2019 | SS | New York Tech |
| Matteo Falcone | NY | Stepinac | 2018 | OF | Ursinus College |
| Brian Forbes | NY | Rocky Point | 2017 | 1B | Herkimer County CC |
| Mateo Gil | NY | Grand Street Campus | 2017 | 3B | Salem University |
| Joseph Greco | NY | Bellport | 2017 | SS | Sacred Heart |
| Christopher Harbin | NY | Patchogue-Medford | 2016 | RHP | Eastern Nazarene College |
| Mario Hernandez | NY | St. Anthony's | 2017 | RHP | |
| Nicholas Jack | NY | St. John the Baptist | 2017 | RHP | |
| Tyler Kaplan | NY | Trinity | 2018 | 3B | |
| Anthony Lambroia | NY | Commack | 2017 | C | |
| John Leonardi | NY | Seaford | 2018 | OF | |
| Nicky Manesis | NY | Shoreham-Wading River | 2017 | OF | Army |
| Mark Maurelli | NY | Newfield | 2017 | OF | |
| Brendan McFall | NY | Oceanside | 2018 | RHP | Tufts University |
| Robert Milopsky | NY | Rocky Point | 2019 | 3B | Hillsborough CC |
| Matthew Panker | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | SS | Colby College |
| Frank Papanikolatos | NY | Patchogue-Medford | 2017 | 1B | |
| Vincent Pecora | NY | Seaford | 2018 | C | |
| Michael Petronis | NY | Commack | 2017 | OF | |
| Tommy Reifler | NY | Garden City | 2019 | SS | Binghamton |
| Steven Rizzo | NY | St. Anthonys | 2019 | OF | Franklin & Marshall College |
| Joseph Rosselli | NY | Ward Melville | 2017 | OF | Monroe College |
| Antonio Silverio | NY | St. John the Baptist | 2018 | RHP | |
| Joseph Stewart | NY | Valley Stream | 2017 | OF | |
| Marc Stockhausen | NY | St. Raymonds | 2019 | 3B | Rockland CC |
| James Weisman | NY | Rocky Point | 2017 | OF | Brookdale CC |