2018 Preseason All-State 1st & 2nd Teams Announced
March 22, 2018
| Pos. | Name | High School | Class | Commitment |
| C | Hayden Jones | Carroll | 2018 | Mississippi State |
| 1B | Mikey Wymann | Center Grove | 2018 | St. Leo |
| MIF | Jared Poland | Cathedral | 2018 | Louisville |
| MIF | Timmy Borden | Providence | 2018 | Louisville |
| 3B | Jack Van Remortel | Carmel | 2018 | Michigan |
| OF | Nicholas Schnell | Roncalli | 2018 | Louisville |
| OF | Grant Richardson | Fishers | 2018 | Indiana |
| OF | Carson Husmann | South Central | 2019 | Illinois State |
| P | Jack Perkins | Kokomo | 2018 | Louisville |
| P | Alex Franklin | Bloomington South | 2018 | Indiana |
| P | Braydon Tucker | Northview | 2018 | Indiana |
| P | Gabe Bierman | Jeffersonville | 2018 | Indiana |
| UTL | Michael Doolin | Andrean | 2019 | Vanderbilt |
PRESEASON ALL-STATE 2ND TEAM
| Pos. | Name | High School | Class | Commitment |
| C | Isaac Bair | Homestead | 2018 | Indianapolis |
| 1B | Bobby Dearing | Lafayette Harrison | 2018 | Western Michigan |
| MIF | Riley Bertram | Zionsville | 2018 | Michigan |
| MIF | Craig Yoho | Fishers | 2018 | Houston |
| 3B | Jay Hammel | South Newton | 2018 | Quincy |
| OF | Jake Armentrout | Wheeler | 2018 | Xavier |
| OF | Cam Farren | Brebeuf | 2018 | Denison |
| OF | Julian Greenwell | Columbus East | 2019 | Indiana |
| P | Bradley Brehmer | Decatur Central | 2018 | Wright State |
| P | Michael Dunkelberger | SB St. Joe | 2018 | Indiana |
| P | Avery Short | Southport | 2019 | Indiana |
| P | Austin Peterson | Chesterton | 2018 | Purdue |
| UTL | Bayden Root | Kokomo | 2018 | Ohio State |