Player Commitments
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos. | Commitment |
| Jacob Coffin | NC | Pro5 Academy | 2022 | LHP | Penn State |
| James Coffland | MN | Springfield | 2022 | - | Ridgewater JC |
| Owen Coffman | IA | Grinnell | 2021 | RHP | Ball State |
| Spence Coffman | MS | Tishomingo County | 2022 | SS | Southeastern Louisiana |
| Drew Coffman | IA | Grinnell | 2019 | - | Central College |
| Max Coffman | OH | Pickerington Central | 2022 | RHP | Heidelberg College |
| Charlie Coffman | WA | Ballard | 2023 | RHP | Whitman College |
| Hayden Coffman | TN | Grace Christian Academy | 2016 | C | Cumberland University |
| Gage Coffman | LA | Barbe | 2021 | RHP | Bossier Parish CC |
| Ryan Coffman | MN | Washburn | 2024 | OF | North Iowa Area CC |
| Beau Coffman | KY | St. Xavier | 2020 | RHP | Wabash Valley JC |
| Sam Coffman | CO | Bear Creek | 2023 | RHP | Umpqua |
| Peyton Coffman | AR | Russellville | 2024 | C | MSU - West Plains |
| Antorius Cofield | MD | Arundel | 2023 | 3B | Moravian College |
| Joshua Cofrancesco | CT | St. Paul Catholic | 2020 | OF | Eastern Connecticut State |
| Griffin Cofsky | MA | Dexter Southfield | 2021 | LHP | Babson College |
| Jacob Cogdell | SC | Chapman | 2023 | RHP | Newberry |
| Brandon Coggin | TN | William Blount | 2021 | RHP | Freed-Hardeman |
| Everett Coggin | AL | Mary G. Montgomery | 2024 | 3B | Auburn-Montgomery |
| Nick Coggins | NC | Southlake Christian | 2024 | OF | UNC Wilmington |
| Zane Coggins | AZ | Corona del Sol | 2023 | SS | Chandler-Gilbert CC |
| Drew Cognac | NC | Marvin Ridge | 2019 | LHP | Belmont Abbey College |
| Liam Cogswell | FL | North Broward Prep | 2019 | OF | Tulane |
| Hunter Cogswell | OH | West Muskingum | 2021 | RHP | Hockiing |
| Aidan Cohall | NY | Walter Panas | 2022 | 1B | St. John's |
| Hunter Cohee | OH | Russia Local School | 2018 | RHP | Urbana University |
| Jared Cohen | NY | Byram Hills | 2022 | SS | Army |
| Alex Cohen | PA | William Penn Charter | 2017 | RHP | Army |
| Josh Cohen | NJ | Indian Hills | 2019 | RHP | Connecticut |
| Justin Cohen | FL | Riverview | 2015 | C | Florida State |
| Harrison Cohen | NY | Cold Spring Harbor | 2017 | RHP | George Washington |
| Steven Cohen | PA | William Penn Charter | 2014 | SS | Lafayette |
| Trevor Cohen | NJ | Holy Spirit | 2022 | OF | Rutgers |
| Daniel Cohen | NY | South Glens Falls | 2022 | RHP | Yale |
| Bennett Cohen | NY | CBA-Albany | 2022 | C | College of Saint Rose |
| Joey Cohen | NY | HAFTR | 2023 | OF | Dominican College (NY) |
| Ziggy Cohen | NY | Bethpage | 2024 | RHP | Molloy University |
| Kurt Cohen | FL | St.Thomas Aquinas HS | 2019 | RHP | Tampa |
| Zach Cohen | NY | Sanford H. Calhoun | 2021 | OF | Alfred State College |
| Andrew Cohen | CT | Loomis Chaffee | 2018 | RHP | Bowdoin College |
| Jonathan Cohen | WA | North Creek | 2020 | LHP | Pacific Lutheran |
| Ben Cohen | CA | Redwood | 2021 | RHP | Pomona-Pitzer Colleges |
| Benjamin Cohen | NY | South Glens Falls | 2024 | RHP | Herkimer County CC |
| Jack Cohen | ON | Ecole secondaire catholique Renaissance | 2023 | RHP | Mineral Area JC |
| Jake Cohen | LA | John Curtis Christian | 2020 | RHP | Pensacola State |
| Jaden Cohen | ON | North Toronto Collegiate Institute | 2022 | 3B | Trinidad State JC |
| Brennan Cohen | AL | Vestavia Hills | 2021 | RHP | Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
| Isaiah Cohens | KS | Goddard | 2019 | SS | Johnson County CC |
| Cooper Cohn | IL | McHenry | 2023 | C | Northern Illinois |
| Grant Cohn | LA | Dunham | 2023 | C | Tulane |
| Robert Cohn | VA | Colonial Forge | 2016 | RHP | Eastern Mennonite |
| Donald Cohoon | MA | Plymouth North | 2018 | SS | Hartford |
| Dante Coia | NJ | Buena Regional | 2021 | OF | Chestnut Hill College |
| Parker Coil | OK | Edmond Memorial | 2022 | LHP | Arkansas |
| Owen Coil | OK | Stillwater | 2024 | 2B | Oral Roberts |
| Clayton Coil | NC | Mooresville | 2022 | RHP | Belmont Abbey College |
| Garrett Coiner | TX | Pearland | 2022 | RHP | Incarnate Word |
| Christian Coipel | FL | Florida Christian | 2016 | OF | Florida International |
| Bailey Coish | AB | Okotoks Dawgs Academy | 2019 | OF | Wabash Valley JC |
| Brandon Cokeley | OH | Carlisle | 2024 | MIF | Mt Vernon Nazarene |
| Collin Coker | TX | Sweeny | 2022 | OF | Texas State |
| Seth Coker | WI | Athens | 2019 | 2B | Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| Brett Coker | TN | Hendersonville | 2018 | SS | Itawamba CC |
| Lukas Coker | MI | Tecumseh | 2018 | 1B | Kalamazoo Valley CC |
| Luke Coker | AL | Northridge | 2017 | SS | Pensacola State |
| Shane Coker | WI | Athens | 2015 | OF | Akron |
| Eric Colaco | OH | Revere | 2021 | OF | Denison University |
| Jack Colagiovanni | MD | John Carroll | 2019 | LHP | Wake Technical CC |
| Aidan Colagrande | NY | Kings Park | 2022 | LHP | Fairfield |
| Hunter Colagrande | NY | Kings Park | 2024 | RHP | Stony Brook |
| Gabe Colaianni | TX | Ridge Point | 2019 | OF | Northwestern State |
| Zachary Colangelo | VA | Colonial Forge | 2023 | OF | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Yogi Colangelo | VA | Battlefield | 2027 | 2B | Virginia Tech |
| Chase Colangelo | VA | Battlefield | 2027 | SS | Virginia Tech |
| Caden Colangelo | VA | Colgan | 2023 | 1B | Emory University |
| Zach Colangelo | IL | Wheaton North | 2016 | OF | North Park University |
| Christian Colangelo | VA | C.D. Hylton | 2016 | 1B | Mary Washington |
| Aiden Colangelo | ON | St. Jean de Bre Beuf | 2017 | 1B | Niagara County CC |
| Myles Colangelo | FL | William T. Dwyer | 2017 | SS | College of Central FL (JC |
| AJ Colarusso | MA | Groton | 2022 | LHP | Boston College |
| Giovanni Colasante | NY | Poly Prep | 2022 | SS | Harvard |
| Juan Colato | NATIONAL | Unknown | 2018 | - | Grand Canyon |
| Ryan Colaw | WV | Petersburg | 2014 | 3B | Garrett JC |
| Brody Colbert | NJ | Williamstown | 2021 | SS | La Salle |
| Patrick Colbert | MD | Georgetown Prep | 2025 | OF | Richmond |
| Nolan Colbert | IN | Hamilton Southeastern | 2024 | OF | Franklin College |
| Sean Colbert | NJ | Audubon | 2020 | 3B | Rowan JC-Gloucester |
| Micah Colbert | ON | EastView Secondary School | 2021 | SS | George Brown College |
| Kaden Colborn | OK | Stillwater | 2018 | OF | Midland JC |
| Nolan Colby | NH | Souhegan | 2024 | 3B | Fairfield |
| Jayden Colclasure | CO | Falcon | 2024 | 3B | Garden City CC |
| Tom Colcombe | PA | Peters Township | 2019 | LHP | Pittsburgh |
| Benjamin Coldiron | NE | Gretna | 2019 | RHP | Concordia (NE) |
| Tyler Colditz | FL | Out-Of-Door Academy | 2021 | SS | Trinity College (CT) |
| Zach Cole | MO | Springfield Catholic | 2019 | - | Ball State |
| Matthew Cole | IL | Rich Central | 2013 | 1B | Alcorn State |
| Phillip Cole | NC | Western Alamance | 2018 | RHP | Appalachian State |
| Eric Cole | TX | Southlake Carroll | 2015 | OF | Arkansas |
| Peyton Cole | NV | Palo Verde | 2019 | SS | Brigham Young |
| Jeremy Cole | IL | Rockford East | 2015 | OF | Chicago State |