2023 PRESEASON ALL-STATE 4A TEAM
| POS. | NAME | SCHOOL | CLASS | COMMITMENT |
| C | Hogan Denny | Mooresville | 2024 | Indiana |
| 1B | John Curl | Kokomo | 2023 | Indiana State |
| INF | Josh Adamczewski | Lake Central | 2023 | Ball State |
| INF | Drew Culberton | Center Grove | 2023 | Missouri |
| INF | Kevin Hall Jr. | Munster | 2023 | Grambling State |
| OF | Garrison Barile | Center Grove | 2023 | Miami (OH) |
| OF | Max Clark | Franklin | 2023 | Vanderbilt |
| OF | Gavin Collins | Northridge | 2023 | Pennsylvania |
| P | Eli Bridenthal | Mt. Vernon | 2023 | Xavier |
| P | Bishop Letson | Floyd Central | 2023 | Purdue |
| P | Kevin Reed | Martinsville | 2023 | Evansville |
| P | Eli Shaw | Warren Central | 2023 | Indiana |
| P | Cameron Tilly | Castle | 2023 | Auburn |
| 2-Way | Jack Brown | Fishers | 2024 | Louisville |
2023 PRESEASON ALL-STATE 3A TEAM
| POS. | NAME | SCHOOL | CLASS | COMMITMENT |
| C | Chance Bentley | Connersville | 2023 | Evansville |
| 1B | Mason Braun | New Prairie | 2025 | Virginia Tech |
| INF | Jace Burton | Silver Creek | 2023 | Indiana State |
| INF | Mason Barth | Andrean | 2025 | Notre Dame |
| INF | Carter Murphy | West Vigo | 2023 | Indiana State |
| OF | Jayce Lee | SB Saint Joseph | 2024 | Notre Dame |
| OF | Jayden Ohmer | Brebeuf | 2023 | John A. Logan |
| OF | Dane Dewees | Silver Creek | 2023 | Southwestern Illinois |
| P | Christian Pownall | Western | 2023 | Ohio State |
| P | Brayton Thomas | Dwenger | 2024 | Indiana |
| P | Cale Coursey | Crawfordsville | 2023 | |
| P | David Edwards | Scottsburg | 2023 | Eastern FL St. |
| P | Joe Chrapliwy | John Glenn | 2024 | |
| 2-Way | Mitchell Dean | Western | 2023 | Louisville |
2023 PRESEASON ALL-STATE 2A TEAM
| POS. | NAME | SCHOOL | CLASS | COMMITMENT |
| C | Chase Long | Delphi | 2023 | Queens University |
| 1B | Ben Seitzinger | Mitchell | 2024 | |
| INF | Grant Borden | Providence | 2023 | Mercer |
| INF | Reid Howard | Forest Park | 2024 | Western Kentucky |
| INF | Gavin Lash | Wapahani | 2023 | Purdue-Northwest |
| OF | Andrew Wiggins | Heritage Chistian | 2023 | Indiana |
| OF | Cole Huett | Providence | 2025 | Virginia |
| OF | Kevin Corcoran | Illiana Christian | 2023 | Webster University |
| P | Alec Hershberger | Fairfield | 2023 | Taylor University |
| P | Corbin Snyder | Eastern | 2024 | Butler |
| P | Luke McDonald | Linton Stockton | 2023 | IU-Kokomo |
| P | Bradley Ferrell | South Central | 2024 | Kentucky |
| P | Sebastian Salazar | Sheridan | 2023 | Jefferson JC |
| 2-Way | Jake Hooker | University | 2023 | Xavier |
2023 PRESEASON ALL-STATE 1A TEAM
| POS. | NAME | SCHOOL | CLASS | COMMITMENT |
| C | Mo Lloyd | Southwood | 2023 | |
| 1B | Edward "Trey" Harney | Greenwood Christian | 2023 | Indiana Wesleyan |
| INF | Brady Yeryar | Shakamak | 2023 | Indiana Wesleyan |
| INF | Brett Sherrard | Bloomfield | 2023 | Butler |
| INF | Alex Schuler | Borden | 2024 | |
| OF | Micah Mackay | Indy Lutheran | 2023 | |
| OF | Seth Wagler | Barr Reeve | 2025 | |
| OF | Dylan Toler | Borden | 2023 | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| P | Benjamin Mazur | Lafayette Central Catholic | 2023 | Murray State |
| P | Camden LaFuze | Union City | 2023 | Indiana Wesleyan |
| P | AJ Agnew | Borden | 2023 | |
| P | Brinn Robbins | Lafayette Central Catholic | 2024 | |
| P | Peyton Merica | Rising Sun | 2023 | |
| 2-Way | Conner Anglin | Tecumseh | 2023 | Southern Indiana |
