Prep Baseball Report

PA Class of 2025 Rankings (Season Update)

Charlie Spano
VP of Scouting PA/NY

Prep Baseball Pennsylvania had a busy winter schedule, packed with the best talent across the state. Now, as the High School season begins, is the perfect time to update the class of 2025 rankings. Some big D1 commitments as well as some other familiar peak performers fill the top 50.  We have also seen some new names emerge over the last few months. In all, 39 players were added to the rankings with an updated watch list to go along with it.  These players have the spotlight on them now as college recruiters begin to focus on their next signing class. Therefore, we expect a clearer picture and some more shake ups to the rankings this summer as this class makes their commitments. Take a look as we break down the top ten and some other positional standouts to our expanded list.

Follow The Team

Interested In Attending A Prep Baseball Pennsylvania Event? Click Here

Interested In Subscribing to Prep Baseball? Click Here

Don't forget to follow along on our social media platforms:

Instagram @PBRPennsylvania || X  @PBRPennsylvania

Class of 2025 Rankings- Click Here

Watch List

The Top Ten

Jason Fultz 3B / RHP / Cathedral Prep, PA / 2025


Josh Toole C / 3B / Hempfield, PA / 2025


Danny Nelson RHP / OF / Hershey, PA / 2025


Evan Jones RHP / OF / Methacton, PA / 2025

Christian Lucarelli RHP / Riverside, PA / 2025


Ben Peterson C / OF / Canon Mcmillan, PA / 2025


Nolan Behm SS / 3B / Central Bucks East, PA / 2025


Kaden Hathaway 3B / RHP / Trinity, PA / 2025


Isaiah Shayter RHP / SS / Elizabethtown Area, PA / 2025


Andrew Pellicciotta SS / 2B / Malvern Prep, PA / 2025


Top Newcomers by Position- 

A closer look at some of the new players added to the 2025 Rankings.

2-Way Player

Evan Wilson RHP / 1B / Conestoga Valley, PA / 2025


Aidan McElhatton RHP / Central HS, PA / 2025



Ryan Cantz LHP / OF / La Salle College HS, PA / 2025





Luke Chartrand 3B / C / North Penn, PA / 2025


AJ DiAddezio SS / RHP / Pope John Paul II (Royersford, PA), PA / 2025



Tyler Gilbert 1B / RHP / Perkiomen Valley, PA / 2025


Sam Heckert C / Pine-Richland , PA / 2025