Prep Baseball Report

NY 2025 Rankings Update


Joe Walentin
Scouting Director, NY

As the fall season is coming to a close and offseason training is in full swing, it’s a perfect time to take a dive into the 2025 rankings. One of the more well-rounded classes in recent memory is led by power arms and high-level athletes up the middle of the field. A few of the power arms leading the way out of NYC, RHP/3B Justice de Jong (Poly Prep), RHP Miguel Sime (Poly Prep) and RHP Erick Peralta (Grand Street).

Included below is a look at the Top 10 in the class, a full list of the 265 ranked players, Player To Watch List, and  Top Uncommitted by position

CLICK HERE FOR THE COMPLETE LIST 265 || CLICK HERE FOR PLAYER TO WATCH LIST

Top 10

Justice de Jong RHP / 3B / Poly Prep, NY / 2025

 

 

Miguel Sime RHP / OF / Poly Prep, NY / 2025

 

 

Erick Peralta RHP / Grand Street, NY / 2025

 

 

Jordan Serrano OF / The Stony Brook School, NY / 2025

 

 

Mateo Noto SS / 2B / Beacon School, NY / 2025

 

 

Owen ten Oever C / 1B / Poly Prep, NY / 2025

 

 

Sebastian Santos-Olson LHP / 1B / Citius Prep, NY / 2025

 

 

Hudson Cavallo RHP / OF / Arlington, NY / 2025

 

 

Todd Feurtado III LHP / OF / St. Mary's, NY / 2025

 

 

Anthony Frobose SS / RHP / Lakeland, NY / 2025

 

 

TOP UNCOMMITTED BY POSITION

Two Way:  Jack Roventini (Poly Prep)

RHP: Rhys Carway (Somers)

 

LHP: Steven Bronson (Beekmantown)

C: Blake Herman (Gowanda)

CINF:  Aaron Lugo (Monroe-Woodbury)

MINF: Miguel Matos (East)

OF: Luke Becker (CBA-Syracuse)