| Rank | Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| 1 | Luke Stephenson | IN | Triton Central | 2012 | RHP | Vanderbilt University |
| 2 | Jordan Minch | IN | Highland | 2012 | LHP | Purdue University |
| 3 | Matt Dauby | IN | Cathedral | 2012 | SS | Virginia Tech University |
| 4 | Will Coursen-Carr | IN | South Side | 2012 | LHP | Indiana University |
| 5 | Nick McCoy | IN | Central Noble | 2012 | RHP | Coastal Carolina University |
| 6 | Isaac Sampen | IN | Brownsburg | 2012 | RHP | Purdue University |
| 7 | Jacob Post | IN | Chesterton | 2012 | RHP | Ohio State University |
| 8 | Jordan Striegel | IN | New Albany | 2012 | SS | University of Louisville |
| 9 | Mitch Patishall | IN | Pendelton Heights | 2012 | 3B | University of Cincinnati |
| 10 | Colin Hawk | IN | Roncalli | 2012 | SS | University of Cincinnati |
| 11 | Conner Hale | IN | Brebeuf | 2012 | RHP | Notre Dame University |
| 12 | Taylor Lehnert | IN | Lake Central | 2012 | RHP | Central Michigan University |
| 13 | Nick McCarty | IN | Cathedral | 2012 | RHP | Notre Dame University |
| 14 | Brian Ghiselli | IN | West Lafayette | 2012 | RHP | Miami (OH) University |
| 15 | Troy Kuhn | IN | Zionsville | 2012 | SS | Ohio State University |
| 16 | Julian Flanary | IN | Lawrence North | 2012 | OF | Miami (OH) University |
| 17 | Clark Pence | IN | Greenfield Central | 2012 | RHP | Morehead State University |
| 18 | Drake Duncan | IN | Ben Davis | 2012 | C | Galveston Junior College (TX) |
| 19 | Jimmy McNamara | IN | Lake Central | 2012 | LHP | Central Michigan University |
| 20 | Tyler Anderson | IN | Hamilton Heights | 2012 | LHP | University of Illinois-Chicago |
| 21 | Drew Small | IN | Zionsville | 2012 | OF | Butler University |
| 22 | Ryan Spaulding | IN | Oak Hill | 2012 | SS | Ball State University |
| 23 | Matt Woolwine | IN | Fishers | 2012 | OF | John A. Logan |
| 24 | Trey Bickel | IN | Mishawaka | 2012 | RHP | Southeastern Illinois College |
| 25 | Grant Wilson | IN | Carroll | 2012 | OF | |
| 26 | Chase Fieldhouse | IN | Lake Central | 2012 | OF | |
| 27 | Nick Weybright | IN | Lawrence North | 2012 | SS | University of Dayton |
| 28 | Adam Bolen | IN | Western | 2012 | 3B | |
| 29 | Conner Strain | IN | North Central (Farmersburg) | 2012 | RHP | University of Evansville |
| 30 | Cody Strong | IN | McCutcheon | 2012 | C | Purdue University |
| 31 | Andrew Hasler | IN | Mishawaka Marian | 2012 | RHP | Valparaiso University |
| 32 | Josh Fisher | IN | Northrop | 2012 | P | University of Dayton |
| 33 | Ryan Levenhagen | IN | Cathedral | 2012 | 1B | Army |
| 34 | Jacob Armstrong | IN | Silver Creek | 2012 | RHP | University of Alabama-Birmingham |
| 35 | Seth Huxford | IN | Concord | 2012 | RHP | |
| 36 | Bryce Yoder | IN | Eastside | 2012 | RHP | Valparaiso University |
| 37 | Evan VanSumeren | IN | South Side | 2012 | OF | |
| 38 | Andre Jernigan | IN | Homestead | 2012 | SS | Xavier University |
| 39 | JP Pena | IN | Fishers | 2012 | SS | |
| 40 | Jordan Humfleet | IN | Pendelton Heights | 2012 | LHP | University of Dayton |
| 41 | Nick Bartolone | IN | Lafayette Harrison | 2012 | OF | Butler University |
| 42 | Connor McLaughlin | IN | Manchester | 2012 | RHP | IPFW |
| 43 | Brandon Soat | IN | Homestead | 2012 | OF | IPFW |
| 44 | Zach Anderson | IN | Center Grove | 2012 | RHP | |
| 45 | Michael McCormick | IN | Speedway | 2012 | RHP | Navy |
| 46 | Karson Bender | IN | Delphi | 2012 | OF | Purdue University |
| 47 | Drew Clark | IN | Fishers | 2012 | OF | Heartland Community College |
| 48 | Tyler Thompson | IN | Penn | 2012 | LHP | |
| 49 | Dane Geisler | IN | Jasper | 2012 | 1B | |
| 50 | Scott Jerge | IN | Munster | 2012 | RHP | Valparaiso University |
| 51 | Alex Benson | IN | Lawrence North | 2012 | C | |
| 52 | Jaylen Quarles | IN | Lawrence Central | 2012 | OF | Northern Kentucky University |
| 53 | Jake Lindeman | IN | Crown Point | 2012 | SS | |
| 54 | Ryan Bertram | IN | Zionsville | 2012 | C | University of Southern Illinois |
| 55 | Cody Frazier | IN | Huntington North | 2012 | OF | Huntington University |
| 56 | Nick Hollowell | IN | Muncie Southside | 2012 | 3B | |
| 57 | Austin Franzen | IN | Warsaw | 2012 | LHP | |
| 58 | Eric McKibban | IN | Ben Davis | 2012 | LHP | University of Evansville |
| 59 | Glenn Jones | IN | Lawrence Central | 2012 | RHP | University of Dayton |
| 60 | Wade Burtron | IN | Westfield | 2012 | OF | |
| 61 | Jake Weber | IN | Homestead | 2012 | OF | Parkland Community College |
| 62 | Tony Rosselli | IN | Terre Haute North | 2012 | OF | Indiana State University |
| 63 | Caleb Baechtold | IN | Bloomington South | 2012 | C | John Hopkins University |
| 64 | Donovan Rhodes | IN | Ben Davis | 2012 | RHP | |
| 65 | Cody Gardner | IN | Terre Haute North | 2012 | SS | |
| 66 | David Jercha | IN | Portage | 2012 | 1B | Indiana State University |
| 67 | Kent Williams | IN | Noblesville | 2012 | RHP | Indiana University |
| 68 | Adam Raifsnider | IN | Elkhart Central | 2012 | C | Taylor University |
| 69 | Josh Caccamo | IN | Homestead | 2012 | OF | |
| 70 | John Jones | IN | Lawrence Central | 2012 | 3B | Southeastern Illinois College |
| 71 | Trevor Jennings | IN | Pendelton Heights | 2012 | C | Danville Area Community College |
| 72 | Ethan Bartrom | IN | Huntington North | 2012 | C | |
| 73 | Hunter McIntosh | IN | Columbus North | 2012 | SS | Alabama State |
| 74 | James Hackworth | IN | Tippecanoe Valley | 2012 | RHP | Indiana State University |
| 75 | Nick Saldutti | IN | Westfield | 2012 | 1B | Butler University |
| 76 | Bobby Humphreys | IN | Chesterton | 2012 | RHP | St. Joseph's College |
| 77 | Brice Stratton | IN | Bloomington North | 2012 | C | Franklin College |
| 78 | John Eberhardt | IN | Pike | 2012 | 2B/MIF | Kentucky Wesleyan University |
| 79 | Kurtis Hussong | IN | Elwood | 2012 | SS | Lincoln Trail Junior College |
| 80 | Tyler Whetstone | IN | Brownsburg | 2012 | OF | |
| 81 | Eric Burnett | IN | New Albany | 2012 | 1B | Southeastern Illinois College |
| 82 | Daniel Sander | IN | Evansville Reitz | 2012 | 1B | |
| 83 | Kendall Whitman | IN | Huntington North | 2012 | 3B | |
| 84 | Bobby Norell | IN | Mishawaka Marian | 2012 | 2B | |
| 85 | Brett Schultheis | IN | Franklin | 2012 | RHP | |
| 86 | Matthew Kaplanis | IN | Blackhawk Christian | 2012 | RHP | |
| 87 | Tyler Hurt | IN | Bloomington North | 2012 | 3B | Cedarville University |
| 88 | Caleb Birkey | IN | Penn | 2012 | OF | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| 89 | Josh Mawhorr | IN | Muncie Central | 2012 | LHP | |
| 90 | Austin Elder | IN | Decatur Central | 2012 | RHP | |
| 91 | Michael Oliphant | IN | Bloomington North | 2012 | SS | |
| 92 | Austin Munn | IN | Central Catholic | 2012 | RHP | |
| 93 | Nick Wright | IN | Roncalli | 2012 | 3B | Bellarmine University |
| 94 | Joel Trewartha | IN | Zionsville | 2012 | 1B | Bellarmine University |
| 95 | Jack Bernacchi | IN | Elkhart Central | 2012 | 1B | Holy Cross College |
| 96 | Brock Sokolowski | IN | Center Grove | 2012 | OF | |
| 97 | Evan Witsken | IN | St. Joseph's | 2012 | SS | Rose-Hulman |
| 98 | Zach Stout | IN | Yorktown | 2012 | OF | |
| 99 | Donnie Waters | IN | Franklin | 2012 | 3B | |
| 100 | Chris Minks | IN | Crawfordsville | 2012 | C | |
| 101 | Jason Simpkins | IN | Roncalli | 2012 | SS | Franklin College |
| 102 | Matt Lampe | IN | Carmel | 2012 | RHP | |
| 103 | Andrew Price | IN | Mishawaka Marian | 2012 | 3B | North Central College |
| 104 | Logan Coughlin | IN | Brownsburg | 2012 | OF | Vincennes University |
| 105 | Nick Barrientos | IN | Zionsville | 2012 | CF | Wabash Valley CC |
| 106 | Jake Kelzer | IN | Bloomington South | 2012 | RHP | Indiana University |
| 107 | Brock Anson | IN | Warsaw | 2012 | SS | |
| 108 | Evan Mohr | IN | Lapel | 2012 | P | Olney Central College |
| 109 | Bobby Carr | IN | Brownsburg | 2012 | C | |
| 110 | David Oliger | IN | Brownsburg | 2012 | 3B | Wabash College |
| 111 | Joel Hobson | IN | Crawfordsville | 2012 | 1B | |
| 112 | Caleb Rasmussen | IN | Crawfordsville | 2012 | OF | |
| 113 | Adam Neidlinger | IN | Guerin Catholic | 2012 | RHP | Eastern Kentucky |
| 114 | Wade McNabb | IN | Evansville Memorial | 2012 | C | |
| 115 | Jordan Gard | IN | Mishawaka | 2012 | LHP | Southeastern Illinois College |
| 116 | Craig Larew | IN | Lawrence North | 2012 | OF | |
| 117 | Mitch Trieglaff | IN | Huntington North | 2012 | C | Parkland Community College |
| 118 | Jake Celleghin | IN | Westfield | 2012 | OF | |
| 119 | Daniel Marlow | IN | Terre Haute South | 2012 | SS | |
| 120 | Ronnie Hawkins | IN | Elkhart Central | 2012 | OF | |
| 121 | Trammell Grimmer | IN | Hamilton Southeastern | 2012 | RHP | |
| 122 | Alec Shull | IN | New Palestine | 2012 | OF | |
| 123 | Kevin Meyer | IN | Greensburg | 2012 | OF | St. Joseph's College |
| 124 | Dylan Whetstone | IN | Brownsburg | 2012 | C | |
| 125 | Trenton Chaney | IN | Pike | 2012 | 2B/MIF | |
| 126 | Blake Baumgartner | IN | Fishers | 2012 | RHP | Anderson University |
| 127 | Jordan Deal | IN | Brownsburg | 2012 | RHP | Bellmont University |
| 128 | Grant Kistler | IN | Hamilton Southeastern | 2012 | OF | |
| 129 | Derrian Smith | IN | Lawrence Central | 2012 | OF | |
| 130 | Patrick Kilma | IN | St. Joseph's | 2012 | OF | |
| 131 | TJ Ehrman | IN | Westfield | 2012 | RHP | |
| 132 | Jordan Carithers | IN | Northridge | 2012 | RHP | |
| 133 | Daniel Jenkins | IN | Perry Meridian | 2012 | C | |
| 134 | Trevor Storie | IN | Huntington North | 2012 | SS | Heartland Community College |
| 135 | Nick Moody | IN | Madison | 2012 | OF | |
| 136 | Michael Carnahan | IN | Lafayette Harrison | 2012 | RHP | |
| 137 | Zach Hull | IN | Northview | 2012 | 1B | Rose-Hulman |
| 138 | Jordan Hamilton | IN | Oak Hill | 2012 | RHP | |
| 139 | Aaron Wells | IN | Cowan | 2012 | C | |
| 140 | Corleone Desimone | IN | Jimtown | 2012 | 2B | Adrian College |
| 141 | T.J. Decker | IN | Northview | 2012 | SS | |
| 142 | Tyler McKeon | IN | Frankton | 2012 | IF | Heartland Community College |
| 143 | Connor Parkison | IN | Lawrence North | 2012 | RHP | |
| 144 | John Hardwick | IN | Perry Meridian | 2012 | RHP | |
| 145 | Tyler Beck | IN | Greenwood | 2012 | RHP | |
| 146 | Chase Steinbrunner | IN | Roncalli | 2012 | RHP | |
| 147 | Michael Brosseau | IN | Andrean | 2012 | SS | Oakland University |
| 148 | Andrew Brown | IN | Speedway | 2012 | RHP | |
| 149 | Ben Seefeldt | IN | Lawrence North | 2012 | 2B/MIF | |
| 150 | Kyle Williams | IN | Southmont | 2012 | 3B |